Do You Love Rich, Creamy, Flavorful Cheesecake?
We thought so...and you're not alone. Grace Cheesecakes began at the Dane County Farmers’ Market on Madison’s glorious Capitol Square in 2006 and our first five years have been a whirlwind! With a 2006 Food & Wine Show win, TEN Taste of Madison awards since our start – including the coveted 2009 “Best of Taste” – and a growing following among local food lovers, restaurants and gourmet grocers, cheesecake lovers everywhere are discovering Grace Cheesecakes! Owner Lori Christilaw, a Culinary Institute of America graduate, creates some of the most delicious and mouth-watering cheesecakes in all of creation.
We Are Shipping Toffee for the Holidays!
I've been wanting to do this for longer than I've wanted to have a cheesecake business and it's finally happening! We use my mother's English Toffee recipe, the one we grew up making and eating during the holidays. It's not the stick-to-your-teeth kind of toffee. It's crisp and tender. The smooth flavors melt in your mouth.
Flavors
Walnut – This is a classic! The only flavor I grew up eating and it's still my favorite. Dark chocolate and loaded with nuts.
Almond – This is our first year with Almond Toffee, and so far it's our best seller! Dark chocolate and sliced almonds.
Peppermint – Frosted with lightly minted white chocolate and dipped into crushed peppermint candies. It's beautiful and tasty too! A holiday favorite.
Coffee Toffee – Our newest creation, we took EVP (local Madison coffee roaster) Espresso Blend beans, chopped them up and threw them right into the toffee and then slathered it with dark chocolate and topped it all with cocoa nibs – YUM!
Prices
4 oz. cellophane bag $5.00
7 oz. box $9.50
14 oz. box $18.50
Shipping Information
- Shipping $18.00 per US Postal package shipped
- Overnight shipping is required for orders placed after December 19th in order to arrive by December 25th. These rates will be based on weight and the "ship to" zip code. When you call in with your credit card information, we can calculate the amount due.
- If you would prefer to pick your order up at the kitchen, please call us to arrange a time.
- View Toffee Shipping Policy
To Order
- Please print and fill out this Toffee Order Form
- Scan and email the Order Form to: gracecheesecakes.com
- Or simply give us a call at 608-516-9888
Where to Find Us 
Right here at our website is one place of course (we are on facebook and twitter too). Read on and get to know us. Visit our Cheesecakes page to view our delicious offerings, and check out our Awards and Raves page and read what others think of our fabulous cheesecakes. Have an order you want to place, or an event you want to discuss with us?
Give us a call at (608) 516-9888 or send us an e-mail from our Contact page.
You can also find Grace Cheesecakes (under the orange canopy!) at the Dane County Farmers’ Market on Madison’s scenic and renowned Capitol Square during it’s outdoor season when Madison is the best place to live.
When the weather gets too cold for our fingers to make change the market moves indoors - first to the Monona Terrace from November to Christmas, then to the Madison Senior Center on West Mifflin from January until the outdoor market season starts again in mid-April. Cheesecake samples are always available so you can taste how yummy they are on the spot!
Enjoy Grace Cheesecakes’ goodies at these fine establishments:
- Barrique’s Market on Hwy PD,
- Beans ‘n Cream in Sun Prairie,
- Cooper's Tavern on the capitol square,
- Fromagination on the capitol square,
- Hawk’s Bar & Grill,
- Indie Coffee,
- Gluten-Free English Toffee at Silly Yak Bakery,
- Vin Santo's in Middleton serves our gluten-free slices,
- Whole Foods Market.
As always, be sure to visit our booth at Madison's amazing Taste of Madison each Labor Day weekend.
It is an honor serving Madison and the surrounding community. And it's a pleasure being a part of this amazing city!